Traditional and Montessori Preschools Compared

Traditional Montessori
Teacher acts as primary enforcer of discipline. Environment and method encourage self-discipline.
Teacher is center of classroom as "controller". Teacher has unobtrusive role in classroom.
Mainly group instruction. Mainly individual instruction.
Same-age group. Mixed-age group.
Most teaching done by teacher. Grouping encourages children to teach and help each other.
Curriculum structured without input from child. Child chooses his/her own work.
Child is guided to concepts by teacher. Child discovers concepts from self-teaching.
Child generally allotted specific time for work. Child works as long as he/she wishes on a chosen project.
Instruction pace set for group norm without regard for individual child. Child sets own learning pace.
Work is corrected, and errors pointed out, by teacher. Child spots own errors from feedback from material or process.
Learning reinforced externally by rewards and punishment. Learning reinforced by repetition of work and internal feelings of success.
Most classroom materials are toys. Multi-sensory materials for physical exploration.
Few organized programs for self-care; up to parents. Organized program for learning care of self and environment.
Children spend most of their day playing with toys or doing crafts. Children select their own materials for learning skills and academics.
Children have very little independence as to work choices and movement; often, group work is all that is allowed. Children can work where they choose, and move around and talk at will, without disturbing others; group work is often voluntary.